Beauty marketing agency proposal scorecard

Scores two or three agency proposals on seven weighted criteria.

Agency proposal scorecard

Proposals to compare
Weights and scores

Set the weights before you open the first proposal. Score each criterion 0 to 5 from what is written. Weights add up to 100.

Scope clarity
Who does the work
Account and data ownership
Reporting against sales
Creator rights and disclosure
Contract terms
References
Flag rule

Total out of 100

  1. Proposal A-7 of 7 scores left.
  2. Proposal B-7 of 7 scores left.
  3. Proposal C-7 of 7 scores left.

A flagged criterion has to be resolved in writing before that proposal can win, whatever its total. The starting weights and cut-offs are our judgment. The scorecard measures how completely a proposal answers what you asked, on paper. It says nothing about results. This is general information, not legal advice.

Comparing agencies? Put us on your list too.

Your numbers come with your message.

Tell us your story

How it works

Give each of seven criteria a whole number from 0 to 5, scoring only what is written in the proposal. Each score is multiplied by its weight, the products are added, and the sum is divided by five times the total weight and scaled to 100.

Any criterion weighted 15 or more that scores 2 or lower is flagged, and a flagged item has to be resolved in writing before that proposal can win. Totals within a few points are best read as a tie.

Read the full guideBeauty marketing agency scorecard: compare proposals side by side10 min read

Tell us your story

Share a little about your brand and what you need help with. We reply within 24 hours.

What do you sell, who do you want to reach, and what would you like to achieve?

Add details (optional)
What can we help with? (optional, choose any)