Beauty marketing agency scorecard: compare proposals side by side
Score two or three beauty marketing agency proposals on seven weighted criteria, with a rubric, a worked comparison and a worksheet to fill in.

How do you compare beauty marketing agency proposals side by side?
Say you run a skincare brand that sells on its own site, and you’re planning a creator program. Three agencies send proposals, which we’ll call A, B and C. Each one looks good. Each is laid out differently. You can’t tell which is best.
Here’s a simple way to compare beauty marketing agency proposals side by side. Score each proposal from 0 to 5 on seven criteria. Multiply each score by a weight you set before reading any proposal. Then compare the totals out of 100.
The seven criteria are scope clarity, who does the work, and account and data ownership. The rest are reporting against sales, creator rights and disclosure, contract terms, and references. Treat a low score on any heavily weighted criterion as a flag to resolve in writing. Do that whatever the total says.
This page is just the scoring sheet. The questions to put to an agency are in our ten questions for a K-beauty marketing agency. Fee ranges are in our guide to what a beauty marketing agency costs. The scorecard names no agencies and says nothing about what any agency charges. Every proposal and score in the worked comparison is invented.
Which criteria go on the scorecard, and how much should each weigh?
Seven criteria cover what a proposal has to settle before you sign, and the starting weights add up to 100. Scope clarity and account and data ownership carry 20 each. Who does the work and reporting against sales carry 15 each. Creator rights and disclosure, contract terms and references carry 10 each.
Those weights are our judgment. No rule or study sets them. Change them to fit your brand, but do it before you open the first proposal. If you set weights after reading, it’s easy to tilt them toward the proposal you already like. For the skincare brand in our example, agree the weights before anyone looks at A, B or C.
The seven criteria with starting weights (our judgment; set your own)
| Criterion | What it covers | Starting weight | Raise it if |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope clarity | Deliverables, quantities, channels, exclusions and what counts as done | 20 | Proposals include different things, so their fees cannot be compared yet |
| Who does the work | Named people, their roles, their time on your account and any subcontractors | 15 | Senior people ran the pitch and you do not know who runs the account |
| Account and data ownership | Whose name is on ad accounts, shops, analytics, creator lists and content files, and what you keep at exit | 20 | You are opening accounts for the first time or leaving another agency |
| Reporting against sales | Which sales figures the report uses, who can check them and how often it arrives | 15 | Past reports showed views and clicks and no orders |
| Creator rights and disclosure | Who contracts creators, usage rights, disclosure instructions and monitoring | 10 | Creators are a large share of the plan |
| Contract terms | Term, notice, handover at exit, fee changes and liability | 10 | The term is long or the notice period is unclear |
| References | Brands you can call, with the agency's role and the dates | 10 | The agency is new to your category or channel |
How do you score each criterion?
Give each criterion a whole number from 0 to 5, based only on what’s in writing. Score what the proposal says. Or score what the agency confirms in writing afterward. A promise made on a call scores 0 until it’s on paper.
The table describes 1, 3 and 5. Use 2 and 4 for answers that fall between. Use 0 when the proposal doesn’t address the criterion at all.
Have two people score separately, then compare. Say you give Proposal B a 2 on ownership and your co-founder gives it a 4. Sit down and reread that part together before you average anything. Do this whenever two scores differ by two points or more. The two-point threshold is our rule of thumb.
Scoring rubric: what 1, 3 and 5 look like for each criterion
| Criterion | Scores 1 | Scores 3 | Scores 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope clarity | A list of services with no quantities | Deliverables and quantities listed; exclusions missing | Deliverables, quantities, exclusions, your team's tasks and a definition of done |
| Who does the work | "Our team" | Roles named, people not named | Named people with roles and time on your account; subcontractors disclosed |
| Account and data ownership | The agency opens accounts in its own name | You own some accounts; others are unclear | Every account in your name, the agency added as a user, exit handover listed |
| Reporting against sales | Platform metrics only | Sales as reported by each ad platform | Sales tied to your order records, method stated, source open to you |
| Creator rights and disclosure | Not mentioned | Usage rights stated; disclosure left to creators | Contract party, rights, disclosure instructions and monitoring all stated |
| Contract terms | Long fixed term, no exit terms | Notice period stated; handover not covered | Notice, handover, fee changes and ownership at exit all in the draft |
| References | Logos only | Case studies with no contact | Contacts you can call, with the agency's role and the dates |
What do the platforms and the FTC say about ownership and creators?
Two criteria rest on rules you can check yourself. We read each page below on November 11, 2026.
On account ownership, the platforms decide who holds control. TikTok Shop’s user management guide, updated June 16, 2026, says that only the shop owner account can add users. Amazon says Brand Registry applications must be submitted by the trademark owner. Google Ads lets you choose an access level each time you grant access.
Google’s help page adds one more point. If a manager account has ownership of your account, the manager’s admin users can also edit user access, managers and product links in it. A manager account is a Google Ads account used to manage other accounts. A proposal that scores 5 on ownership says which of these the agency will hold. It also says which stay with you. We didn’t check Meta’s rules on partner access, so Meta isn’t covered here.
On creators, the FTC’s guidance on its Endorsement Guides says that handing part of a promotional program to an outside company doesn’t relieve the brand of responsibility under the FTC Act. It says advertisers need reasonable programs to train and monitor the people who promote for them. That means four things. Explain what they can and can’t say. Tell them to disclose their connection. Search now and then for what they’re saying. Act on questionable practices.
The same guidance says a company that pays and directs influencers for a brand needs such a program too. The FTC’s advertising guide for small businesses adds that ad agencies have a duty to make an independent check on the information used to back up ad claims. Score a proposal that leaves disclosure entirely to the creators at 3 or lower. This is general information, not legal advice.
How is the scorecard total calculated?
Multiply each score by its weight and add up the seven results. Divide by five times the sum of the weights. Multiply by 100 and round to one decimal place. When the weights add up to 100, that’s simply the sum of the results divided by 5. A proposal that scores 5 on everything gets 100. One that scores 0 on everything gets 0.
Then apply one flag rule. Any criterion you weighted 15 or more that scores 2 or lower is flagged. A flagged item has to be resolved in writing before that proposal can win, whatever its total. The cut-offs of 15 and 2 are our judgment. Tighten or loosen them, but fix them before you score.
If two totals are within a few points, treat them as tied. The scale is short. One reader’s 3 can be another reader’s 4, so a small gap tells you very little. Break the tie on flags first. Then break it on the criterion you weighted highest.
What does a finished comparison of agency proposals look like?
Here’s the finished comparison for the skincare brand from the start, with its three invented proposals, A, B and C. The brand sells on its own site and plans a creator program. The example uses the starting weights. No proposal, score or agency in it is real.
Each cell in the table shows the score and, in brackets, the score times the weight. Proposal A: 80 + 45 + 100 + 45 + 40 + 30 + 20 = 360, and 360 divided by 5 is 72.0. Proposal B: 60 + 75 + 40 + 60 + 30 + 40 + 40 = 345, which gives 69.0. Proposal C: 100 + 30 + 80 + 60 + 20 + 50 + 30 = 370, which gives 74.0.
Proposal C has the highest total and a flag. It scored 2 on who does the work, a criterion weighted 15. Proposal B is flagged on ownership. Proposal A has no flag, because its 2 on references sits on a criterion weighted 10. The two-point gap between C and A is too small to decide anything.
So the brand’s next step is to ask C to name the people on the account in writing. Then ask A for references it can call. Rescore both.
Three invented proposals scored with the starting weights: score, with score times weight in brackets
| Criterion (weight) | Proposal A | Proposal B | Proposal C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope clarity (20) | 4 (80) | 3 (60) | 5 (100) |
| Who does the work (15) | 3 (45) | 5 (75) | 2 (30) |
| Account and data ownership (20) | 5 (100) | 2 (40) | 4 (80) |
| Reporting against sales (15) | 3 (45) | 4 (60) | 4 (60) |
| Creator rights and disclosure (10) | 4 (40) | 3 (30) | 2 (20) |
| Contract terms (10) | 3 (30) | 4 (40) | 5 (50) |
| References (10) | 2 (20) | 4 (40) | 3 (30) |
| Sum of score x weight | 360 | 345 | 370 |
| Total out of 100 | 72.0 | 69.0 | 74.0 |
| Flags | None | Account and data ownership | Who does the work |
What happens to the scores when you change the weights?
Changing the weights can reorder the proposals even when every score stays the same. Suppose the same skincare brand decides creators are half the plan. It moves 5 points from scope clarity and 5 from contract terms to creator rights and disclosure. That gives weights of 15, 15, 20, 15, 20, 5 and 10. The scores don’t change.
Proposal A: 60 + 45 + 100 + 45 + 80 + 15 + 20 = 365, or 73.0. Proposal B: 45 + 75 + 40 + 60 + 60 + 20 + 40 = 340, or 68.0. Proposal C: 75 + 30 + 80 + 60 + 40 + 25 + 30 = 340, or 68.0.
C drops from first to joint last. It also picks up a second flag, because its 2 on creator rights now sits on a criterion weighted 20. The ranking moved because the brand said what mattered to it. That’s the reason to set your weights first.
The same three invented proposals under two sets of weights
| Weight set | Proposal A | Proposal B | Proposal C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting weights | 72.0, no flag | 69.0, flag on ownership | 74.0, flag on who does the work |
| Creator-heavy weights | 73.0, no flag | 68.0, flag on ownership | 68.0, flags on who does the work and creator rights |
What should an agency proposal say about reporting against sales?
A strong proposal reports against your own sales records, not just the numbers each ad platform shows. A report built on views, clicks and purchases as each platform counts them can’t be checked against your order records.
A proposal scores 5 on this criterion when it does three things. It names the sales source, such as your store’s orders or a marketplace’s settlement reports. It says how sales are attributed, meaning how credit for each sale is assigned, and where that method falls short. And it gives you access to the underlying data. Ask each agency to show the report layout it would send, filled in with one of your past months.
It helps to have your own baseline before proposals arrive. Want help building sales reporting from your own order data first? That’s the work of Dahna’s analytics and growth strategy service. After you sign, our guide to what a digital marketing agency should do in its first 30 days covers the first report.
What else do founders ask about scoring agency proposals?
How many proposals should you score? Two or three. If you have more, shortlist on your two heaviest criteria. Then score the ones left in full.
What if every proposal scores low on one criterion? Your brief probably didn’t ask for it. Send one follow-up question to every agency and rescore.
Does a high total mean the agency will perform? No. The scorecard measures how completely a proposal answers what you asked, on paper. It says nothing about results.
What should you do before you open the first proposal?
Start from the worksheet. It has the criteria, starting weights, rubric and worked comparison, plus blank columns for your proposals. For the wider decision, read how to choose a marketing agency for your beauty brand. All beauty and K-beauty marketing guides are on one page.
Dahna is a new agency with no client results to publish, so score our proposal on the same sheet. Our skincare page describes how Dahna works with skincare brands.
Then do these five things before anyone reads a proposal.
- Set the seven weights and the flag rule, and write down who agreed to them.
- Send the criteria to every agency with the same brief, so each proposal answers them.
- Have two people score each proposal separately, from the written text only.
- List every flag and ask for a written answer before you rescore.
- Compare fees last, for the same scope, because a lower fee for a thinner scope is a different buy.
In summary
To compare beauty marketing agency proposals, score each one 0 to 5 on seven criteria. Apply weights you set before reading, then compare totals out of 100. A score of 2 or lower on a criterion you weighted 15 or more is a flag. Resolve it in writing before that proposal can win.
Sources & further reading
- FTC's Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking (checked November 11, 2026)Federal Trade Commission
- Advertising FAQ's: A Guide for Small Business, April 2001, edited January 2025 (checked November 11, 2026)Federal Trade Commission
- How to use User Management, updated June 16, 2026 (checked November 11, 2026)TikTok Shop Academy (US)
- Requirements and tips for enrolling a brand in Amazon Brand Registry (checked November 11, 2026)Amazon
- About access levels in your Google Ads account (checked November 11, 2026)Google Ads Help
Know your own sales numbers before you compare agencies.
Dahna is a new agency, founded in January 2026, with no client results to publish. If you want sales reporting built from your own order data before proposals arrive, or want our proposal scored on this sheet, tell us what you are comparing.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Platform and FTC pages were read on November 11, 2026 and can change.



