Beauty influencer campaign diagnosis checklist
Finds where a campaign lost sales with eight checks from reach to purchase.
Sources, checked
Campaign diagnosis checklist
Mark each of the eight checks, from reach to purchase, to see what to fix first.
Next to check: Step 8, Volume
The eight checks, from reach to purchase
- Creators and audienceWhether each creator's viewers are in the US and buy this kind of product.
Why it matters
The wrong audience can bring high views and very few link clicks.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it last, after the mechanics pass. Judgments about people are easier once you know the counting and the links worked, so skip it until steps 8, 7, 4, 6 and 5 are done.
Common pitfalls
- Judging a creator on one video. One strong video does not make a creator a fit, and one weak one does not rule a creator out.
- Reading comments about the creator's life as interest. In our view, questions about shade, price or shipping suggest people who might buy, and comments about the creator's life tell you little about the product.
Where to look
The creator's audience report from the platform; comments on the videos. A problem looks like this: high views, comments about the creator and few about the product; most viewers outside the US.
- BriefWhether each video shows the product in use, names it and says where to buy.
Why it matters
A video that entertains and never says how to buy can collect views and no clicks.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it near the end, after the mechanics pass. Skip it while volume, counting, links, stock or the product page are still open.
Common pitfalls
- Watching without sound. Note when the product first appears and whether the creator says its name and where to buy it.
- Leaving the name, where to buy and the offer out of the brief. Put them in before the first video goes live.
Where to look
The brief you sent; the posted videos. A problem looks like this: the product appears late or briefly; the name or the place to buy is missing.
- Reason to buy nowWhether there was an offer, a deadline or a launch.
Why it matters
Without an offer, a deadline or a launch, viewers may have no reason to buy now.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it with the brief, after the mechanics pass. Skip it while volume, counting, links, stock or the product page are still open.
Common pitfalls
- Videos that praise the product and give no price, offer or end date.
- Judging every campaign on sales. Views without sales may have value, and this checklist does not measure it, so decide the goal first.
Where to look
The brief, the captions, your promotion calendar. A problem looks like this: videos praise the product and give no price, offer or end date.
- Link and codeWhether every link opened the right page and every code applied at checkout.
Why it matters
If a link or a code fails, viewers who clicked may never reach the product or cannot use the offer.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it early, right after volume and counting: it is a fact in your own systems. It needs a unique tagged link and code for each creator; without both it cannot be run.
Common pitfalls
- Testing on a computer. Test on a phone, from inside the app where the video ran.
- Checking only that the link opens. Confirm it lands on the featured product with the campaign tags still in the address.
- Letting creators retype links. UTM values are case sensitive, so send links ready to paste.
Where to look
Your own test on a phone; the link tool's click report; the discount report. A problem looks like this: clicks with no sessions; a code that returns an error; a link to the home page.
- Product page and priceWhether the page matches the video and the total with shipping is what viewers expected.
Why it matters
If tagged sessions arrived and few added to cart, look at the page those viewers landed on; if carts stopped at shipping, look at the total at checkout.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it once volume, counting, links and stock pass. If clicks never turned into tagged sessions, look at step 4 first.
Common pitfalls
- Comparing the price without shipping and tax. Compare the checkout total with the price said in the video.
- A page that shows a different shade, size, claim or offer from the video.
- Judging the add-to-cart rate against a benchmark. We found none we could verify; compare with your own sessions from other sources over the same days.
Where to look
Store analytics for campaign sessions: product page, cart and checkout steps. A problem looks like this: sessions arrive and few add to cart, or carts stop at shipping.
- Stock and shippingWhether the featured product and shade were in stock throughout, and what delivery time was shown.
Why it matters
A featured shade that sold out on day three is a simpler explanation for a flat second week than anything about the creators.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it early, with links and codes: it is a fact in your own records. If sales stopped partway through, a stock-out is the likely cause.
Common pitfalls
- Checking total stock instead of each shade or size.
- Forgetting delivery time. Look at the delivery estimate shown at checkout on the campaign days.
Where to look
Inventory history; order and support records. A problem looks like this: sold out during the posting days; long delivery estimates.
- CountingWhether the report you read missed orders.
Why it matters
Each tracking method misses orders in a known way, so sales can happen that your report does not count.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it second, right after volume, before judging the creators or the videos. Wait at least as long as the attribution window of the report you are reading. For TikTok Shop ads, TikTok's help page gives a window of 7 days after a click and 1 day after a view.
Common pitfalls
- Reading one report. Orders that used a creator's code and carried no campaign tag were missed by the link report.
- Treating code orders as exact. A code can spread beyond the creator's audience, so in our view code orders are an upper estimate.
- Expecting two TikTok reports to agree. For TikTok Shop ads, Seller Center reports sales on the day; TikTok Ads Manager reports them within the attribution window.
Where to look
Tagged-link report, discount code report, marketplace reports, post-purchase survey. A problem looks like this: code orders exceed tagged orders; direct and search orders rise during the campaign.
- VolumeWhether there were enough videos, clicks and orders to conclude anything.
Why it matters
A small campaign cannot answer the question. With a few dozen clicks, zero orders and three orders are hard to tell apart.
When to check it, and when you can skip it
Check it first, every time. In our judgment, if one order more or less would change your conclusion, the finding is that the test was too small, and the next step is a larger test with the same tracking.
Common pitfalls
- Ranking creators on too few orders. Enough orders to say a campaign sold something can still be too few to compare creators.
- Looking for a published minimum. We know of none; look for enough sessions that one order more or less would not change your conclusion.
- Deciding the threshold afterwards. Decide how many videos and sessions you need before the first video goes live.
Where to look
Counts of videos posted, clicks, sessions and orders. A problem looks like this: a handful of videos or a few dozen clicks.
Campaign counts
Optional whole numbers for the campaign period. A blank count leaves its rates not available. No rate is judged against a benchmark.
- Share who postedCreators who posted / creators sent x 100
- Not available
- Click rateLink clicks / video views x 100
- Not available
- Tagged share of clicksTagged sessions / link clicks x 100
- Not available
- Untagged clicksLink clicks - tagged sessions
- Not available
- Add-to-cart rateAdd to cart / tagged sessions x 100
- Not available
- Tagged order rateOrders with the tag / tagged sessions x 100
- Not available
- Orders identifiedOrders with the tag + code orders without it
- Not available
- Identified order rateOrders identified / tagged sessions x 100
- Not available
- Uncounted shareCode orders without the tag / orders identified x 100
- Not available
Found the problem? We can help fix it.
Your checklist comes with your message.
The fix-first order is our judgment: facts in your own systems before judgments about people and creative. No step carries an industry benchmark, because we found none we could verify from a primary source. Platform help pages were read on November 11, 2026 and can change.
Sources, checked November 11, 2026
- TikTok Business Help Center, About attribution for TikTok Shop Ads (last updated August 2025)TikTok Shop ads attribution window: 7 days after a click, 1 day after a view; Seller Center and Ads Manager count sales differentlyNo date on the page. Read November 11, 2026.
- Google Analytics Help, URL builders: Collect campaign data with custom URLsUTM parameter values are case sensitiveNo date on the page. Read November 11, 2026.
How it works
The eight checks follow the buyer from seeing the video to receiving the order. Run them in fix order: step 8 first, then 7, 4 and 6, then 5, and last 3, 2 and 1.
The later steps are facts you can look up, such as whether the link, the code and the stock worked. The early ones are judgments about people and creative, and they are easier to make once you know the counting and the mechanics worked. Mark each check to see what to fix first.
Read the full guideWhy didn't our influencer campaign sell? A diagnosis checklistTell us your story
Share a little about your brand and what you need help with. We reply within 24 hours.